1. United States
2. Md.
3. Letter

The passage of the Antisemitism Awareness Act raises valid concerns about protecting free speech rights and preventing the suppression of legitimate criticism. As a nation committed to democratic values, it is crucial that legislation aimed at combating hate does not inadvertently infringe upon constitutionally protected freedoms of expression. There are apprehensions that this Act could potentially hinder justified condemnation of actions by the state of Israel that violate international humanitarian law, such as the use of disproportionate force against civilians, the infliction of collective punishment, and the weaponization of hunger. These grave transgressions, which include disturbing reports of sexual violence, cannot be shielded from scrutiny under the guise of combating antisemitism. It is imperative to strike a balance between addressing the undeniable rise in antisemitic incidents and safeguarding the right to voice dissent against policies and actions that contravene human rights norms. The Act's broad definition of antisemitism risks casting a chilling effect on legitimate criticism of the Israeli government's conduct in the occupied Palestinian territories. Therefore, I urge you to oppose this legislation unless revisions are made to narrow its scope and provide robust protections for free speech rights, ensuring that it does not suppress vital public discourse on matters of profound moral and geopolitical significance. A more nuanced approach is needed to uphold both the fight against antisemitism and the fundamental principles of open dialogue and government accountability.