1. United States
  2. N.C.
  3. Letter

An Open Letter

To: Rep. Harris, Sen. Budd, Sen. Tillis

From: A verified voter in Waxhaw, NC

November 6

I urge you to support a constitutional amendment that preserves the President’s vital power to grant mercy while allowing courts to invalidate a pardon proven to have been procured through bribery or another felony. Clemency can correct unjust sentences, recognize rehabilitation, and help the nation move beyond conflict. But an unchecked pardon can also erase punishment, undermine public confidence, and in some cases relieve recipients of fines or restitution owed to victims and taxpayers. Recent reporting has described pardon-broker networks and clemency actions that bypassed ordinary review, while Congress has raised concerns about billions of dollars in financial penalties being forgiven. These reports warrant a durable safeguard, not partisan retaliation against any particular president. The various Pardon Integrity Acts and Abuse of the Pardon Prevention Acts allowing Congress to trigger a review or challenge or nullify a pardon are good ideas, but seem unlikely to survive judicial review. Congress should have standing to bring a challenge a pardon when credible evidence indicates criminal procurement. But making legislators the decision-makers would draw Congress directly into individual clemency disputes and invite partisan votes over particular recipients. An independent judicial determination under a clear evidentiary standard would be a more principled way to decide whether a pardon was obtained by crime. The amendment should be explicit. It should preserve the President’s authority to grant pardons and commutations, but provide that a grant may be invalidated by the Supreme Court upon evidence beyond a reasonable doubt that bribery or another felony caused it. Congress should be authorized to seek review, alongside other parties Congress defines with a concrete stake. The amendment should also allow the Court to invalidate only the affected financial relief when a corrupt bargain concerned fines or restitution, without automatically restoring a custodial sentence. Victims’ vested rights should be protected. A constitutional amendment is required. The Supreme Court has treated the pardon power as exceptionally broad and held that Congress cannot simply limit its effect by ordinary legislation. Statutes that try to impose substantive restrictions may therefore face serious constitutional challenges. An amendment, properly ratified, can establish the narrow exception directly while leaving the ordinary power intact. Please support a bipartisan amendment establishing judicial review for pardons procured through felonious conduct, and support Congress’s authority to bring such challenges. No president should lose the power to show mercy. No president should be able to convert that power into protection purchased by crime.

Share on BlueskyShare on TwitterShare on FacebookShare on LinkedInShare on WhatsAppShare on TumblrEmail with GmailEmail

Write to Mark Everette Harris or any of your elected officials

Send your own letter

Or text write to 50409

Resistbot is a chatbot that delivers your texts to your elected officials by email, fax, or postal mail. Tap above to give it a try or learn more here!