1. United States
2. Ohio
3. Letter

I am writing to express my strong opposition to the Coast Guard's proposed policy regarding the display, use, or promotion of certain symbols, specifically swastikas and nooses. While I understand the intent behind this policy, I believe it represents a dangerous overreach that could infringe upon the constitutional rights of Coast Guard personnel. Admiral Kevin Lunday's statement that any instances involving these symbols will be subject to "thorough investigation and severe punishment" is deeply concerning. This approach fails to consider context, historical significance, or educational purposes, and could lead to unjust persecution of individuals who may not have malicious intent. The blanket ban on these symbols, regardless of context, sets a troubling precedent. For instance, the swastika has significant religious importance in Hinduism, Buddhism, and Jainism, predating its misappropriation by the Nazi regime. A policy that doesn't account for these nuances could inadvertently discriminate against service members of these faiths. Moreover, this policy could hinder educational efforts about historical events, including the Holocaust and the history of racial violence in America. The ability to discuss and learn from history, including its darkest chapters, is crucial for developing a well-informed and culturally sensitive military force. I urge you to intervene and demand a more nuanced approach from the Coast Guard. Any policy addressing hate symbols must balance the need to combat extremism with the protection of free speech and religious freedom. It should include clear guidelines for context-based evaluation and protect educational and historical uses of these symbols. Please take immediate action to review and revise this policy before its implementation. Our service members deserve a policy that upholds both their rights and the values of inclusivity and respect that the Coast Guard aims to promote. The current proposal, as stated by Admiral Lunday, falls short of this balance and requires your immediate attention and intervention.