1. United States
2. N.Y.
3. Letter

This proposed legislation, the Stop Terror-Financing and Tax Penalties on American Hostages Act, contains provisions that raise concerns. While supporting Americans unlawfully detained abroad is important, terminating the tax-exempt status of organizations deemed by the Treasury Department to have provided "material support" to certain groups is problematic. This risks violating free speech and association rights without sufficient due process. The broad definition of "material support" could unfairly target civil society organizations working in conflict zones. Furthermore, allowing evidence to be withheld from judicial review undermines transparency and accountability. I urge you to oppose this bill unless revised to address these civil liberties issues. There may be better ways to assist detained Americans and counter terrorism financing that do not compromise constitutional principles or chill legitimate nonprofit activities. A more tailored approach safeguarding robust legal protections would be preferable to the expansive powers proposed here. This complex issue merits further examination to strike the right balance.