- United States
- N.Y.
- Letter
Oppose S. 836 (COPPA 2.0) — Protect Privacy Without Age Verification
To: Rep. Mannion
From: A verified voter in Syracuse, NY
November 16
I am your constituent, and I urge you to oppose S. 836, the Children and Teens' Online Privacy Protection Act — so-called "COPPA 2.0" — when it reaches the House floor.
I support protecting kids' privacy, but this bill would achieve the opposite. Its central flaw is that it replaces COPPA's "actual knowledge" standard with "knowledge fairly implied on the basis of objective circumstances." As the Electronic Frontier Foundation explained in its letter of concern, that is essentially a negligence standard — one of the lowest thresholds in law — and it will push general-audience websites toward sweeping, privacy-invasive age-verification gates for every visitor.
To extend protections to users under 17, platforms must first determine who is under 17 — and the reliable way to do that is to check everyone. As Reclaim The Net put it, this is "age verification wearing a privacy label." In practice, that means ID uploads, facial scans, and biometric databases: honeypots of sensitive data on the very young people the bill claims to shield, and a serious erosion of adult anonymity and free speech online.
These are not fringe concerns. A coalition of more than fifty civil rights and advocacy groups — organized by Fight for the Future and including organizations like the Muslim Justice League and the United American Indians of New England — has warned that age-verification mandates endanger marginalized communities and core civil liberties, especially LGBTQ youth, religious minorities, and young people seeking health information.
The data-minimization and targeted-advertising limits in this bill are worthwhile goals, but they can be achieved without mass identity checks. Congress should instead pass comprehensive consumer privacy legislation that protects all users — of every age — without incentivizing sites to collect more identity data, not less.
Please oppose S. 836 and champion a comprehensive privacy framework instead. I would welcome your response on how you plan to vote.