An open letter to State Governors & Legislatures (N.Y. only)

Constituent question: SAFE for Kids Act after the IDScan.net breach

1 so far! Help us get to 5 signers!

I'm a New Yorker writing about the SAFE for Kids Act, and I'm asking you to work toward its repeal — or at minimum, a fundamental reworking of how it handles age verification. Last week's IDScan.net breach shows exactly why. A dark-web marketplace called Nexus started advertising 153 million scans of driver's licenses, along with more than 10 million other identity cards, travel documents, and medical cards. The data traces back to a single Louisiana verification company, one used at over 20,000 locations nationwide. Brian Krebs confirmed his own license was in the dump. So was the Defense Secretary's. The FBI opened an investigation on September 1. This is the industry New York law now forces websites to rely on. Under the SAFE for Kids Act, any site hosting content a minor might see has to verify ages before granting access — and the practical way to do that at scale is exactly the kind of third-party database that just got emptied onto the dark web. Every New Yorker who verifies their age under this law becomes a new record in someone else's honeypot. And once a license scan leaks, it leaks permanently — feeding identity theft and, perversely, giving kids better fake IDs than ever. I don't doubt the law's supporters care about children. But we can protect minors online without building a statewide queue of identity documents held by private contractors we can't secure. Parental controls, device-level defaults, and privacy-preserving approaches don't require collecting anyone's license photo. Albany passed this law with good intentions. The breach is evidence of where those intentions lead. Please reconsider it — and if full repeal isn't on the table, tell me what you'll support to ensure no New Yorker's ID ends up for sale on Exploit because the state demanded it be collected in the first place. I'd genuinely appreciate a substantive reply.

▶ Created on September 3 by Online Privacy for America

Sign Petition

Or text Sign PITFGO to 50409

Already signed?

  • Promote this campaign to get it texted to potential signers
  • Share this page or image
    A shareable card that reads "tell State Governors & Legislatures (N.Y. only): Constituent question: SAFE for Kids Act after the IDScan.net breach" followed by "text sign PITFGO to 50409"
  • Text INVITE PITFGO to ask your friends to sign via text or email
  • and post around campus or on your community bulletin board
  • Use the iOS app to share with your contacts
  • Join our Discord and connect with fellow organizers
  • Upgrade to Premium to unlock more features and make sure we can keep delivering
Share on BlueskyShare on TwitterShare on FacebookShare on LinkedInShare on WhatsAppShare on TumblrEmail with GmailEmail

Fund texts of this petition

Drive more letter deliveries by funding text appeals to users. Become a member to double your reach per dollar.