An open letter to the President & U.S. Congress

Silence Is Not Neutrality

65 so far! Help us get to 100 signers!

At a rally in Nebraska last night, President Trump reportedly talked about Iran “taking out” Los Angeles and San Diego and described the destruction as a “small price to pay” for ending the war. And the crowd cheered. They cheered at the prospect of American cities being destroyed. They cheered at the thought of American families being killed. There are moments when politics has to end and morality has to begin. This is one of those moments. I am demanding that you publicly and unequivocally condemn President Trump’s remarks—and condemn the crowd that cheered them. Because silence is not neutrality. Imagine if a Democratic president had said that the destruction of Los Angeles and San Diego was an acceptable price to pay, and a Democratic crowd had cheered. Would you remain silent? I hope not. American lives should not depend on which political party occupies the White House. Los Angeles isn’t an abstraction. San Diego isn’t an abstraction. They are American cities filled with American people—children, parents, teachers, nurses, firefighters, workers and families. Those people are not a “price.” We can disagree passionately about Iran, war, foreign policy and the president. But there should be one line that no political party crosses: American civilians are not expendable. No president should normalize the idea that the destruction of American cities and the deaths of millions of Americans are an acceptable bargain. And no political movement should cheer it. So I am asking you to do something that should not be controversial: Condemn the statement. Condemn the cheering. Defend the value of American civilian life. Do not hide behind partisan politics. Do not wait for someone else to speak. History remembers moments like this. It remembers the people who spoke. It remembers the people who acted. And it remembers the people who heard what was happening, understood the danger, and chose silence. Silence is not neutrality. It becomes part of the historical record. You took an oath to serve the people of this country. Serve them now. Speak clearly. Stand up. And make sure that when history looks back at this moment, your name is not on the list of people who saw what was happening and decided that political convenience was more important than moral courage. History is watching and So are we.

▶ Created on October 6 by Katheryne

Sign Petition

Or text Sign PKVGSQ to 50409

Already signed?

  • Promote this campaign to get it texted to potential signers
  • Share this page or image
    A shareable card that reads "tell the President & U.S. Congress: Silence Is Not Neutrality" followed by "text sign PKVGSQ to 50409"
  • Text INVITE PKVGSQ to ask your friends to sign via text or email
  • and post around campus or on your community bulletin board
  • Use the iOS app to share with your contacts
  • Join our Discord and connect with fellow organizers
  • Upgrade to Premium to unlock more features and make sure we can keep delivering
Share on BlueskyShare on TwitterShare on FacebookShare on LinkedInShare on WhatsAppShare on TumblrEmail with GmailEmail

Fund texts of this petition

Drive more letter deliveries by funding text appeals to users. Become a member to double your reach per dollar.