Oppose FDA Overreach on Chest Binders for Transgender People

I am writing to urge you to oppose the FDA's recent crackdown on chest binders used by transgender people. FDA Commissioner Marty Makary recently sent 12 warning letters to manufacturers and retailers, claiming that chest binders are medical devices requiring FDA registration because they treat gender dysphoria. This action represents dangerous government overreach that will harm vulnerable people in your district. The FDA's justification is inconsistent with its own policies. Attorneys at Hyman, Phelps & McNamara note that it is rare for the FDA to send warning letters regarding low-risk devices, especially over procedural registration issues. The warning letters don't actually cite health risks to minors or document harm. They simply declare binders are medical devices that must be registered, a classification that defies common sense. This policy will have devastating real-world consequences. Point of Pride, a nonprofit that distributes free binders, receives about 40 requests per day from people with an average age of 22, many living in poverty. Restricting access to safe, commercially-made binders will force people back to dangerous DIY methods. Jamison Green, 77, recalls binding in the early 1980s using ACE bandages and cut girdles from Sears. Sean Ebony Coleman, 58, used electrical tape wrapped around ACE bandages, which caused lasting back problems and posture issues. Modern binders made of nylon and spandex are significantly safer. The transgender community is already aware of safe binding practices, including taking breaks throughout the day and never sleeping while binding. Despite minor discomfort, binding supports mental health and allows transgender people to function in daily life without constant judgment and harassment. I urge you to publicly oppose this FDA action and work with colleagues to ensure transgender people retain access to safe chest binders. This is about basic dignity and safety for constituents in your district.