- United States
- N.Y.
- Letter
I'm writing to urge you to oppose the SCREEN Act (S.737 / H.R.1623). While it's framed as protecting minors, this bill would establish nationwide age verification requirements covering a dangerously broad range of websites — everything from adult sites to popular social media platforms, fanfiction communities, and even entire telecommunications networks. In practice, that means ordinary Americans would have to hand over government IDs, passports, or biometric data like facial scans just to browse legal content.
This creates severe risks that outweigh any claimed benefit. Websites would be forced to contract with third-party verification companies that collect and store highly sensitive identifying information in databases that have repeatedly been breached. Under the bill, users' IP addresses would be tied to their identities, allowing browsing histories to be tracked. The bill even targets VPNs directly — requiring age checks on known VPN traffic — effectively attacking one of the last widely available privacy tools Americans use to protect themselves online.
There's also the very real problem of censorship. With vague, sweeping definitions of what constitutes "content harmful to minors," this legislation hands enormous discretionary power to whichever administration and regulators happen to be in office. Similar state laws have already been used to classify constitutionally protected expression as "harmful to minors." The SCREEN Act would nationalize that approach.
Age verification mandates don't meaningfully protect children — determined minors find workarounds while every adult user bears the privacy risk and every lawful site bears the burden of censorship-by-compliance.
I strongly urge you to reject the SCREEN Act and instead support measures that genuinely protect children online, such as sensible parental controls and enforcing data minimization standards, without forcing adults to surrender their anonymity and identity to access the open internet.
Thank you for your consideration.