1. United States
  2. N.Y.
  3. Letter

STOP CSAM (S.1829 / H.R.3921) would mandate surveillance. Vote NO.

To: Rep. Mannion, Sen. Gillibrand, Sen. Schumer

From: A verified voter in Syracuse, NY

November 14

I'm writing to urge you to oppose the STOP CSAM Act (S.1829 / H.R. 3921), which was reported out of the Judiciary Committee in June 2025 and is now waiting for floor time. I know how hard it is politically to vote against a bill with "Stop CSAM" in the title—but please don't let that name coerce your vote. Voting no on a bad bill is not voting against child safety; it's refusing to be blackmailed by branding. The children this bill claims to protect will be less safe under it. The bill creates a "recklessness" liability standard that lets platforms be sued over user content. That turns offering end-to-end encryption into a legal risk: a service that cannot scan messages—because they're encrypted—can be painted as reckless by design. Nobody has to outlaw encryption if providing it becomes an uninsurable lawsuit. This is the EARN IT playbook with a friendlier cover. The bill also builds a Report-and-Remove regime: notified providers get just 48 hours to take content down, and a new Child Online Protection Board of three FTC attorneys can order removal of every copy of material—and not just CSAM, but other content relating to a person—while fining providers up to $200,000. Combined with pressure on Section 230 protections, this hands government appointees broad censorship power over lawful speech. Weakened encryption endangers the very people most at risk: LGBTQ+ youth, survivors of domestic violence and stalking, and journalists and activists who rely on private communication. Experts widely agree that real child safety online comes from strong data privacy protections—not from mandating surveillance of everyone's private messages, which sets an alarming precedent for government snooping on all of us, children included. I understand the political optics. But your constituents deserve a representative who votes on a bill's substance, not its title. Please oppose the STOP CSAM Act, oppose any similar attempts to weaken encryption, and support comprehensive data privacy legislation instead.

Share on BlueskyShare on TwitterShare on FacebookShare on LinkedInShare on WhatsAppShare on TumblrEmail with GmailEmail

Write to John W. Mannion or any of your elected officials

Send your own letter

Or text write to 50409

Resistbot is a chatbot that delivers your texts to your elected officials by email, fax, or postal mail. Tap above to give it a try or learn more here!