- United States
- N.Y.
- Letter
Oppose S.5090: Don't Turn Every Device Into an ID Check
To: Sen. Gillibrand, Sen. Schumer
From: A verified voter in Syracuse, NY
November 21
I urge you to oppose S.5090, the Digital Age Assurance Act of 2026, currently before the Senate Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation.
This bill would require the operating system on every device sold in the United States to collect a date of birth and assign every user an age bracket — under 13, 13–15, 16, or 17-and-up — which apps, app stores, and browsers would be obligated to treat as the primary indicator of that person's age. Users could not operate their devices without an account tied to that declaration, and users under 17 would be linked to a parent's account. If conflicting age information surfaces, the operating system provider must verify the user's age. Violations carry fines up to $7,500 per intentional violation per child.
Privacy and civil liberties organizations, including EFF and the ACLU, have long warned that age-verification mandates compromise everyone's rights to protect the youngest users, and this bill raises those concerns to the device level:
1. It ends anonymous computing. An age declaration plus mandatory account makes the device itself a gatekeeper to the internet.
2. It creates a honeypot. Centralized age data on nearly every American is an irresistible target for breaches and misuse.
3. It chills lawful speech. Adults accessing constitutionally protected material would be de-identified and profiled.
4. It is easily circumvented by children via borrowed accounts or false inputs, while imposing surveillance infrastructure on everyone else.
Please oppose S.5090 and any similar device-level age-mandate legislation.