- United States
- N.Y.
- Letter
On Election Day, voters across the country sent a clear message about automated license plate readers (ALPRs). In York, Maine, nearly three-quarters of voters approved removing their town's ALPR cameras and requiring future installations to win voter approval. In League City, Texas, voters ordered police to stop using ALPRs—the cameras came down within days. And Pflugerville, Texas passed a charter amendment mandating privacy protections and oversight for surveillance and facial recognition technologies.
As the Electronic Frontier Foundation put it: "Surveillance is a choice, not a mandate." New Yorkers agree, and recent events here prove the stakes.
In September, an Albany County Sheriff's Office investigator was arrested after allegedly running more than 4,000 unauthorized searches in the Flock system—tracking her ex-girlfriend's car roughly 3,000 times over two years. In Troy, the City Council voted to end the city's Flock contract after resident opposition, only to be overridden when the mayor declared an emergency to keep the cameras up. On November 9, the Assembly held a public hearing on ALPR data collection, and even law-enforcement witnesses conceded the need for real oversight.
New York should follow the voters' lead and act now:
1. Pass A.10808-A/S.9890-A, which would restrict ALPR use to legitimate purposes, block out-of-state law enforcement from accessing New York's data without judicial authorization, and require deletion within 48 hours absent a warrant or active investigation.
2. Require public transparency and audits — every agency operating ALPRs should disclose camera locations, data-sharing partners, and regular audits of search logs, so abuses like Albany County's don't stay hidden for two years.
3. Respect local democratic control — municipalities that vote to reject or remove surveillance technology should not have that decision overridden.
Voters nationwide have shown where they stand. I urge you to bring New York law in line.