1. United States
  2. N.Y.
  3. Letter

Stop Fake Holiday Discounts: Fix America's Deceptive Pricing Rules

To: Sen. Schumer, Rep. Mannion, Sen. Gillibrand

From: A verified voter in Syracuse, NY

November 17

With Black Friday, Cyber Monday, and the peak of the holiday shopping season just days away, millions of Americans are about to rely on advertised "deals" to guide their purchases. Yet the rules governing those claims are vague, fragmented, and aimed at the wrong question — and shoppers are paying the price. The FTC's Guides Against Deceptive Pricing (16 C.F.R. Part 233) require only that a struck-through "former price" be an "actual, bona fide price" offered "on a regular basis for a reasonably substantial period of time" — none of which is defined. Most states simply apply this standard through general consumer-protection laws, producing a patchwork that is nearly unenforceable. Worse, these rules ask whether the advertised list price was honest, not whether the sale price is actually lower than what shoppers recently paid. A retailer can fully comply while offering a "deal" no cheaper than the product's usual price. Groundwork Collaborative's report, "Deal or Decoy? Amazon's Deceptive Discounts," shows how easily this happens in practice. Of 351 Amazon "deals" examined, 29.1% were priced the same or higher than the product's lowest price in the preceding 30 days — rising to 57.3% looking back 90 days. Nearly 1 in 10 "deals" (9.4%) were priced higher than in the prior month. During Black Friday 2025 specifically, more than 4 in 10 "deals" were no cheaper than the price a month earlier, and over 14% were actually higher. Independent checks echo these findings: the Dutch Consumers' Association found over 40% of Amazon's "deals" offered no discount versus pre-sale prices. The holiday season makes reform urgent — but it also demands immediate action: First, the FTC should issue renewed guidance and announce enforcement intent regarding the Guides Against Deceptive Pricing before peak holiday shopping, signaling that inflated reference prices will not be tolerated this season. Second, Congress should require retailers to disclose the lowest price charged for an item in the prior 30 days whenever advertising a discount — the approach the EU adopted in Directive 2019/2161 — and direct the FTC to resume active enforcement. Consumers deserve honest, verifiable price comparisons this holiday season. I urge your leadership on this matter.

Share on BlueskyShare on TwitterShare on FacebookShare on LinkedInShare on WhatsAppShare on TumblrEmail with GmailEmail

Write to Charles E. Schumer or any of your elected officials

Send your own letter

Or text write to 50409

Resistbot is a chatbot that delivers your texts to your elected officials by email, fax, or postal mail. Tap above to give it a try or learn more here!