1. United States
2. Ala.
3. Letter

I urge you to oppose HB 43 and HB 511, which would mandate daily prayer in Alabama public schools and penalize school districts that fail to comply by cutting state funding by up to 12.5%. These bills undermine both religious freedom and educational equity by using financial coercion to impose religious practices in public schools. While I support the right to personal prayer, these bills cross a constitutional line by making organized prayer a condition of full state funding. School districts already struggling financially, particularly those serving high poverty communities and students with special needs, would face impossible choices between their budgets and their constitutional obligations. As House Minority Leader Anthony Daniels noted during committee hearings on March 5, some school systems are already in precarious financial situations despite recent needs-based funding improvements. Stripping administrative funding still impacts the people who work directly with children, as Rep. Barbara Drummond pointed out. The social pressure these bills would create is equally troubling. Stephanie Butler, a Vestavia Hills resident, testified that her Jewish children faced peer pressure as early as elementary school when weekly Bible study was held in the cafeteria and Gideons distributed Bibles to fifth graders. She explained that students who opt out risk being singled out or labeled as outsiders. This is not theoretical concern but documented experience from Alabama families. Prayer is deeply personal and takes many forms across different faiths and traditions. Current Alabama law already permits voluntary prayer and religious studies outside school buildings, allowing students genuine religious freedom without government coercion. Rep. Ingram's claim that HB 511 is non-denominational ignores the reality that organized school prayer inevitably reflects majority religious practices, marginalizing students from minority faiths or no faith. I ask you to vote against both versions of this legislation and protect both religious liberty and equitable school funding for all Alabama students.