- United States
- N.Y.
- Letter
I urge you to oppose the GUARD Act (S.3062 / H.R.8623), which has been reported out of the Senate Judiciary Committee and placed on the Senate calendar. Although it is framed as child safety legislation, in practice it is a sweeping surveillance mandate that would affect every American who uses an AI chatbot—including customer service and search assistants.
The bill requires every user of an AI chatbot to verify their age through a "commercially reasonable" system collecting identifying information such as a government ID, credit record, or biometric data—and mandates periodic re-verification. This creates massive databases of highly sensitive identity information held by private companies and their third-party vendors, exactly the kind of honeypot hackers and bad actors target. As the Electronic Frontier Foundation has documented, these mandates endanger privacy and free expression for everyone, not just minors.
The GUARD Act would also block all minors from AI tools outright—with no parental consent option, no appeal process for verification errors, and no flexibility. Teens would lose access to legitimate, widely used digital tools like search assistants. Courts are already striking down similar age-verification schemes on First Amendment grounds, as happened in Virginia.
Even well-intentioned child-safety bills are misguided if they are built on invasive age verification. The ACLU has warned that censorship and age-verification measures will not keep children safe—they threaten free speech and put everyone's data at risk. Real safety comes from transparency requirements, data minimization, and tools that give parents choices rather than blanket bans.
Please oppose the GUARD Act and support privacy-protective, evidence-based approaches to online safety instead.