1. United States
  2. N.Y.
  3. Letter

Vote NO on S.5720/S.5723. Don't let "child safety" turn into chat surveillance.

To: Sen. Gillibrand, Sen. Schumer

From: A verified voter in Syracuse, NY

November 19

I'm writing to ask you to oppose S. 5720, the Ending Forced Arbitration of Children Online Act, and S. 5723, the No Forced Arbitration for Child Sexual Exploitation and Cyber Injuries Act. I want to be clear: I understand why these bills sound appealing. Ending forced arbitration for child sexual exploitation cases, and letting families sue in open court instead of being blocked by terms of service nobody reads, is a sympathetic goal. But the scope of both bills goes far beyond that worthy aim, and the practical consequences will likely harm the very people they aim to protect. S. 5723 defines a "child cyber injury" as virtually any personal injury to a minor — including mental suffering and emotional distress — caused by the design or operation of any app, platform, AI system, or game, regardless of whether third parties contributed. It even reaches pending cases regardless of when the conduct occurred. S. 5720 is broader still: it covers any platform "reasonably likely" to be used by a minor — which is most of the internet — for claims of psychological harm or privacy violations. With liability exposure that sweeping, platforms won't respond by making their services safer; they'll respond defensively. We've already seen where these design-defect lawsuits lead: mandatory age and ID verification for every user, monitoring of private messages, weakening or dropping of encryption for minors' chats, and aggressive content removal. Privacy itself gets recast as the defect. Ironically, collecting IDs and scanning children's communications would put more sensitive data and conversations at risk. These bills essentially turn open-ended litigation into a lever for mass surveillance of online communication. There are better ways to address child exploitation and platform safety that don't require verifying and watching everyone. Please vote no on S. 5720 and S. 5723, and instead support narrower, targeted measures that punish actual wrongdoing without dismantling privacy for all users.

Share on BlueskyShare on TwitterShare on FacebookShare on LinkedInShare on WhatsAppShare on TumblrEmail with GmailEmail

Write to Kirsten E. Gillibrand or any of your elected officials

Send your own letter

Or text write to 50409

Resistbot is a chatbot that delivers your texts to your elected officials by email, fax, or postal mail. Tap above to give it a try or learn more here!