1. United States
  2. N.Y.
  3. Letter

Don't Make Platforms DEA Informants — Oppose S.2316/H.R.4518

To: Sen. Gillibrand, Rep. Mannion, Sen. Schumer

From: A verified voter in Syracuse, NY

November 15

As your constituent, I urge you to oppose S.2316 / H.R.4518, the Cooper Davis and Devin Norring Act. This bill would require communication providers — social networks, email services, and messaging apps — to scan user communications for suspected drug activity and report them directly to the Drug Enforcement Administration under a mandatory regime modeled on child-abuse reporting, with penalties for failure to comply. This framework is fundamentally different and dangerous for three reasons. First, it turns private companies into deputized federal informants. Once a provider faces liability for failing to report what users say, it must monitor private conversations continuously and forward them to a law-enforcement agency without any warrant, probable cause, or judicial oversight anywhere in the process. Second, it threatens encryption itself. End-to-end encrypted messaging services cannot scan message contents in transit — so a reporting obligation creates direct pressure to weaken or abandon encryption, or to build client-side scanning that inspects messages on your device before they're encrypted. Such mandates would undermine the cybersecurity of every American, exposing journalists, abuse survivors, businesses, and ordinary users to criminals and hostile actors alike. Third, the machinery does not stop at fentanyl. The Electronic Frontier Foundation warned when earlier versions of this bill were introduced that a mandatory keyword-reporting regime is easily expandable: swap in any other disfavored topic and the same surveillance apparatus applies. Once the infrastructure exists, its scope grows. I understand the genuine tragedy of fentanyl overdose and the intent behind the victims' names on this bill. But mass suspicionless scanning of private communications is neither effective nor consistent with the Fourth Amendment. Compassionate, evidence-based approaches exist that do not require every American's private messages to flow to the DEA. Please vote against this legislation and oppose any future mandatory reporting regimes that force companies to surveil their users.

Share on BlueskyShare on TwitterShare on FacebookShare on LinkedInShare on WhatsAppShare on TumblrEmail with GmailEmail

Write to Kirsten E. Gillibrand or any of your elected officials

Send your own letter

Or text write to 50409

Resistbot is a chatbot that delivers your texts to your elected officials by email, fax, or postal mail. Tap above to give it a try or learn more here!